Author Kris Olejniczak Cybersecurity

Blog space

Security Awareness Training – What Actually Changes Employee Behaviour (and What Does Not)

In this article you will read:

  • Why one-off training is not enough to reduce phishing and BEC risk
  • How to build an awareness program based on regular simulations, feedback and role-specific content
  • Which metrics show whether employees actually report threats instead of only completing e-learning

Updated: 13 October 2026

What is an effective security awareness programme? A security awareness programme is a set of educational and behavioural activities designed to change employee attitudes and behaviours in relation to information security – enabling staff to recognise and respond appropriately to threats such as phishing, social engineering, and insider threat.

Verizon DBIR 2024 found that the human element was present in 68% of all data breaches. The most common organisational response is a 45-minute annual e-learning module. The problem is that behavioural science is unambiguous on this point: a one-time training event changes behaviour for several weeks, after which the effect fades. A programme delivered annually to satisfy ISO 27001 Annex A Control 6.3 does not reduce risk – it is compliance theatre.

Security awareness training – at a glance:

  1. There is no universal training or simulation frequency suitable for every organisation.
  2. A durable programme should combine recurring communication, practical exercises and role-relevant training rather than rely on a single annual module.
  3. Simulation results should be interpreted using click or interaction rates, reporting rates, time to first report, repeated behaviour and campaign difficulty.
  4. MFA significantly reduces account-compromise risk but does not prevent every form of BEC, process fraud, session theft or MFA-bypass phishing.
  5. Role-specific content should reflect actual decisions and access. Finance, helpdesk, administrators and board members face different scenarios.
  6. Workers should be informed that a simulation and monitoring programme exists, although individual campaign dates and templates do not need to be disclosed.
  7. ISO 27001 does not mandate monthly or quarterly phishing simulations. The programme should be appropriate to the organisation’s risks, roles and controls.
  8. Patronusec provides phishing simulations and security awareness training as standalone engagements or as part of wider vCISO support, subject to the agreed scope.

Why does annual e-learning not change behaviour – and what works instead?

Behavioural science provides several principles of lasting behaviour change that dramatically increase the effectiveness of awareness programmes when applied:

Principle 1 – Spaced repetition
Durable retention requires multiple exposures at regular intervals. Annual training = one exposure. Monthly phishing simulation = 12 exposures per year. Effectiveness increases exponentially with repetition frequency – this is not intuitive, but it is well established.

Principle 2 – Immediate contextual feedback (teachable moments)
An employee who clicks a simulated phishing link receives a notification immediately: “This was a simulated attack. Here is why it was suspicious and what to do next time.” Feedback delivered at the moment of the event is orders of magnitude more effective than generic training delivered 6 months earlier.

Principle 3 – Positive reinforcement over punishment
Programmes that penalise employees for clicking (mandatory additional training, reports to HR) build fear and encourage concealment of mistakes. Programmes that reward reporting – even false positives – build a security culture. An employee who reports a suspicious email that turns out to be legitimate has done exactly the right thing.

Principle 4 – Role-specific content
BEC attacks target finance. Vishing targets helpdesk and reception. Insider threat is most relevant to IT. Deepfake fraud targets the board. Finance staff need to know how to verify a change of bank details. They do not need a tutorial on configuring two-factor authentication.

Patronusec Insight: We regularly hear: “we trained everyone and we have 100% completion rate.” Completion rate is the worst metric for an awareness programme. What we measure is the reporting rate: what percentage of employees reported a suspicious message in the past 3 months. Organisations where this figure is 10 to 20% have a genuine security culture. Organisations with 100% completion and 0% reporting have a paper programme. In our phishing simulation and training service, we shift this metric from the very first simulation cycle.


Your awareness programme is primarily annual e-learning and you want to know what to change to generate real results?

Patronusec conducts a baseline phishing simulation – without notifying employees in advance – and delivers a report with click, open, and reporting rates by department. Results ready within 10 working days.

Book a baseline phishing simulation


What does an effective 12-month security awareness programme look like?

Month 1: Baseline phishing simulation
Launch a phishing simulation with no advance warning to employees. Measure open rate, click rate, credential submission rate, and reporting rate. This is your baseline – the reference point for all subsequent measurement and the starting evidence for board reporting.

Months 2 to 12: Monthly cycle

Each month, one element from a rotating set:

  • Phishing simulation (email, smishing, vishing in rotation)
  • Role-specific training module (finance, IT, board, operations)
  • Security communication (real-world incident summary with a key learning)
  • Desk reminder (physical or digital reinforcement of one specific behaviour)

Topics that must be covered across 12 months:

  • BEC and the process of verifying changes to payment details
  • Deepfake fraud – how to verify financial requests arriving via video or audio calls
  • URL analysis – how to inspect a domain before clicking
  • Password managers and MFA – why and how
  • Physical security (tailgating, clean desk, document shredding)
  • Incident reporting – where and how to report a suspicious event
  • Shadow IT and the risks of using unapproved AI tools with company data

Programme metrics to track:

MetricTarget after 12 months
Phishing simulation click rateBelow 5% (from a typical baseline of 15 to 30%)
Suspicious message reporting rateAbove 20%
Role-specific training completion rateAbove 95%
Time from simulation send to first reportBelow 15 minutes

How do AI and deepfakes change what your awareness programme needs to cover?

Awareness content written in 2021 taught employees to recognise phishing by grammar errors, awkward phrasing, and generic greetings. AI-generated phishing in 2025 produces zero grammar errors, a natural tone matched to the target organisation’s communication style, and personalisation drawn from LinkedIn profiles and publicly available email history. The traditional linguistic warning signs no longer apply reliably.

What must be added to the programme:

Process-level verification rather than linguistic analysis: Instead of “does this email look suspicious?” – “does this request bypass normal approval workflows?” Any financial request that skips the standard authorisation chain, any request combining urgency with secrecy, any request for credentials outside an official system – these are process-level warning signs, independent of the quality of the language.

Deepfake awareness for finance teams and board members: A video call featuring the apparent CEO is not sufficient authorisation for a financial transfer. Any request above a defined threshold requires confirmation via a second, independent channel – a phone call to a known, registered number, not a callback to a number provided in the request itself.

Shadow AI and company data in AI tools: Employees use ChatGPT, Claude, and other AI tools for work – sometimes with company data. The programme must clearly define what may be entered into AI tools (non-confidential, unclassified material) and what must never be (customer data, commercial secrets, regulated data).

Patronusec Insight: The highest-ROI investment in phishing risk reduction we observe across client organisations is not a new technology purchase – it is changing one cultural norm: “there are no stupid questions; if in doubt, report it to security.” Organisations where reporting is the norm rather than a source of embarrassment detect attacks in hours rather than days. This cultural shift is something our vCISO programme introduces through board communication and management modelling, not only through training modules.

FAQ – Security Awareness Training Programme

How often should phishing simulations be run?

At minimum quarterly (the standard for ISO 27001 compliance and many cyber insurance policies), ideally monthly. Monthly simulations create 12 teachable moments per year and allow trend measurement. Annual simulations do not reduce risk – they exist for compliance reporting only.

Can phishing simulation results be shared with HR?

This is a sensitive ethical and legal question, particularly under UK GDPR and employment law. Best practice: results reported at department level rather than individual level; feedback to the individual is immediate and educational, not disciplinary. Important: inform employees that a simulation programme exists (without revealing dates) – this reduces legal risk and organisational resistance without removing the learning value.

How do you measure ROI from a security awareness programme?

Compare: (a) the cost of a human-factor security incident in your sector (a BEC incident typically costs £30,000 to £300,000 in direct losses) against the expected click rate reduction after 12 months of the programme; (b) cyber insurance premium reductions available with a documented awareness programme. For most organisations, ROI is positive from the first avoided BEC incident.

Does e-learning alone satisfy ISO 27001 Annex A Control 6.3?

ISO 27001:2022 Annex A Control 6.3 requires “information security awareness, education and training.” It does not prescribe format or frequency, but requires evidence of effectiveness (Clause 9.1). An ISO 27001 auditor may challenge a programme consisting solely of e-learning with 100% completion but no measurable behavioural outcomes as failing to demonstrate effectiveness.

Which phishing simulation platforms are worth considering?

Commonly used platforms: KnowBe4, Proofpoint Security Awareness Training, Microsoft Attack Simulator (for Microsoft 365 environments). Selection criteria: a template library relevant to your industry, reporting by role and by template, automated cycle management, and HR system integration for starters and leavers. Patronusec delivers programmes on the client’s existing platform or on our own simulation infrastructure.

How much does a phishing simulation programme cost with Patronusec?

Pricing depends on headcount, number of simulations per year, and the scope of role-specific training. After a free scope-assessment call, we provide a fixed annual programme price. For clients in the vCISO model, the awareness programme is included in the ongoing engagement. A baseline simulation with report is priced as a separate, lower-cost starting project.


Security awareness training – free consultation

Patronusec delivers phishing simulation programmes and security awareness training with measurable outcomes – as a standalone project or as part of our vCISO service.

In a free 30-minute consultation we will help you:

  • Assess the current state of your awareness programme (metrics, frequency, role-specific coverage)
  • Plan a baseline simulation and a 12-month calendar of simulations and training
  • Identify high-risk roles requiring dedicated content (finance, board, helpdesk)
  • Define programme metrics worth reporting to the board as security KPIs

Free consultation | Phishing training and simulations | vCISO | ISO 27001 | NIS2

START THE CONVERSATION

Talk to an assessor

Tell us what you need and we will help you find the right next step.

20-minute scoping call
No obligation
Speak directly with a specialist, not a salesperson