Back to all case studies
CASE STUDY Security Testing

How We Cut Phishing Susceptibility From 45% to Under 5% in One Year for a Polish IT Services Company

A Polish IT services company with around 800 employees did not know how its staff would behave in a real attack. The first test, built on publicly available information about a company event, fooled around 45% of people. After a year-long programme with tests of comparable difficulty, the rate fell below 5%, and more than 60% of employees now report suspicious messages.

Read the Full Story
CLIENT CONTEXT

Who the client is and the challenge they brought to us

Industry

The client is a Polish IT services company whose customers include financial sector organisations. The programme covered around 800 employees in technical, sales, administration, finance and HR teams. Some teams have access to the company’s customers’ systems.

The Challenge

The company’s customers had started to require evidence of regular security awareness training and testing in their supplier assessments. The company was also preparing for supply chain security requirements arising from the NIS2 Directive (EU) 2022/2555. Until then, it had run only one-off e-learning courses. The board wanted to know how easy it would be to deceive the company, in a way that could be measured and improved.

What Was at Stake

An IT company with access to customers’ systems is an attractive target: a successful attack on it can open the way to its customers. An incident would mean cost, lost trust and risk to contracts, especially with the financial sector. Without measurable results, the company had no answer to customers’ questions in supplier assessments.

OUR APPROACH

One month to deploy and run the first test, then a year-long programme

  1. The Platform and the Ground Rules

    We deployed KnowBe4, the platform Patronusec uses as its preferred solution for training and phishing simulation (we are a KnowBe4 partner), within the company’s infrastructure. We configured email in line with the client’s security policy and added a button for reporting suspicious messages. With the board and HR, we agreed the rules: results are for learning, not for judging employees.

  2. A Test Built on What the Company Publishes Itself

    The first scenario, agreed with the board, used publicly available information about an upcoming company event. Around 45% of people were fooled. The test showed how real attackers work: they gather information from open sources (OSINT), such as the company website, social media and announcements, and use it to build a credible message.

  3. Training and a Conversation With the Board

    We prepared short training sessions tailored to each department, with different scenarios for technical teams and for sales and administration. The board received a briefing note and presentation translating the result into business risk: what could have happened in a real attack and what an incident would cost a company handling customer data.

  4. Monthly, With No Easy Tests

    Simulations ran monthly, and the board received a quarterly report. Every test had a difficulty level comparable to the first: never trivial, always hard to spot. A drop in results therefore reflects a real change in behaviour, not easier scenarios.

  5. Role-Targeted Testing

    The client wanted tests to cover specific departments and people, selected by risk. We rebuilt the programme while it was running: with the board, we identified finance (fake invoices, bank account change requests, executive impersonation), HR (fake CVs with attachments), system administrators and people with access to customers’ systems. Each group received scenarios matching real attacks on its role.

  6. A Result the Company Can Show Customers

    After a year, the share of people who fall for phishing had dropped below 5%. The share of employees reporting suspicious messages rose from a few percent to more than 60%, and more than 95% completed the training. The company uses the programme report in supplier assessments run by its customers.

RESULTS & SUCCESS METRICS

Concrete figures showing the impact of the engagement

  • ~800 employees in the programme
  • 45% of people fooled in the first test
  • <5% of people fooled after one year
  • 60%+ of employees report suspicious messages
  • 95%+ of employees completed training
  • 12 simulations a year of comparable difficulty
  • 4 risk groups with their own scenarios

The board has a measurable answer to how easy it would be to deceive the company, and a report it can show customers. For finance, the fall from 45% to under 5% is a concrete reduction in the risk of a costly incident that justifies the spend. For security, a reporting rate above 60% means employees have become an early warning system.

What Our Client Says

Feedback from the client's team after the engagement

"The result of the first test surprised me: almost half of our people clicked on a message based on information about our own event, which we had published ourselves. Patronusec presented it as a lesson in how attackers work, not as catching staff out, which is why the team accepted the programme without resistance. That decided us to test all year rather than once. Today customers ask about our security as a supplier, and we have numbers to answer with. We now build customer trust with data, not assurances."

CEO Polish IT services company

"Finance is a real target: fake invoices, requests to change bank account details, messages impersonating the board. When the tests moved to specific roles mid-year, my team received scenarios that looked exactly like the attacks they might face. It was the biggest change in vigilance I have seen. As CFO, I look at the result: from 45% to under 5% at the same test difficulty. This spend has a measurable return in risk we no longer carry."

CFO Polish IT services company
Frequently Asked Questions

Answers to the questions people in a similar position ask us

Not if the rules are clear from the start: results are for learning, not for judging people. In this programme, we agreed that with the board and HR before the first test and presented the result as a lesson in attacker methods. The outcome was a rise in suspicious message reporting to more than 60%.

Only then does a falling click rate reflect a real change in behaviour. If tests became easier over time, results would look better but would say nothing about the company’s resilience. In this programme, every test was comparable to the first.

The NIS2 Directive puts weight on supply chain security and cyber hygiene training. Companies serving organisations within its scope increasingly need to show that their staff are regularly trained and tested. A measurable programme report provides that evidence.
START THE CONVERSATION

Facing a Similar Challenge?

Want to know how easily your team could be deceived, and improve it measurably? Let’s talk about an awareness and phishing testing programme tailored to the roles in your company.

Free 20-min scoping call
No obligation
Senior assessor not sales